II
A small
selection of hokku (1) on butterflies will help to illustrate
Japanese interest in the aesthetic side of the subject. Some are pictures
only,-- tiny color-sketches made with seventeen syllables; some are nothing
more than pretty fancies, or
graceful suggestions;-- but the reader will
find
variety. Probably he will not care much for the verses in themselves.
The taste for Japanese
poetry of the epigrammatic sort is a taste that must
be slowly acquired; and it is only by degrees, after patient study, that
the possibilities of such
composition can be fairly estimated. Hasty
criticism has declared that to put forward any serious claim on
behalf of
seventeen-syllable poems "would be absurd." But what, then, of Crashaw's
famous line upon the
miracle at the marriage feast in Cana?--
Nympha pudica Deum vidit, et erubuit. [1]
Only fourteen syllables -- and
immortality. Now with seventeen Japanese
syllables things quite as wonderful -- indeed, much more wonderful -- have
been done, not once or twice, but probably a thousand times... However,
there is nothing wonderful in the following hokku, which have been selected
for more than
literary reasons:--
Nugi-kakuru [2]
Haori sugata no
Kocho kana!
[Like a haori being taken off -- that is the shape of a
butterfly!]
Torisashi no
Sao no jama suru
Kocho kana!
[Ah, the
butterfly keeps getting in the way of the bird-catcher's pole! [3]]
Tsurigane ni
Tomarite nemuru
Kocho kana!
[Perched upon the temple-bell, the
butterfly sleeps:]
Neru-uchi mo
Asobu-yume wo ya --
Kusa no cho!
[Even while
sleeping, its dream is of play -- ah, the
butterfly of the
grass! [4]
Oki, oki yo!
Waga tomo ni sen,
Neru-kocho!
[Wake up! wake up! -- I will make thee my comrade, thou
sleepingbutterfly. [5]]
Kago no tori
Cho wo urayamu
Metsuki kana!
[Ah, the sad expression in the eyes of that caged bird! -- envying the
butterfly!]
Cho tonde --
Kaze naki hi to mo
Miezari ki!
[Even though it did not appear to be a windy day, [6] the
fluttering of
the butterflies --!]
Rakkwa eda ni
Kaeru to mireba --
Kocho kana!
[When I saw the fallen flower return to the branch -- lo! it was only a
butterfly! [7]]
Chiru-hana ni --
Karusa arasou
Kocho kana!
[How the
butterfly strives to
compete in lightness with the falling
flowers! [8]]
Chocho ya!
Onna no michi no
Ato ya saki!
[See that
butterfly on the woman's path,-- now
fluttering behind her, now
before!]
Chocho ya!
Hana-nusubito wo
Tsukete-yuku!
[Ha! the
butterfly! -- it is following the person who stole the flowers!]
Aki no cho
Tomo nakereba ya;
Hito ni tsuku
[Poor autumn
butterfly!-- when left without a comrade (of its own race),
it follows after man (or "a person")!]
Owarete mo,
Isoganu furi no
Chocho kana!
[Ah, the
butterfly! Even when chased, it never has the air of being in a
hurry.]
Cho wa mina
Jiu-shichi-hachi no
Sugata kana!
[As for butterflies, they all have the appearance of being about seventeen
or eighteen years old.[9]]
Cho tobu ya --
Kono yo no urami
Naki yo ni!
[How the
butterfly sports,-- just as if there were no
enmity (or "envy")
in this world!]
Cho tobu ya,
Kono yo ni nozomi
Nai yo ni!
[Ah, the
butterfly! -- it sports about as if it had nothing more to desire
in this present state of existence.]
Nami no hana ni
Tomari kanetaru,
Kocho kana!
[Having found it difficult indeed to perch upon the (foam-) blossoms of
the waves,-- alas for the
butterfly!]
Mutsumashi ya! --
Umare-kawareba
Nobe no cho. [10]
[If (in our next existence) we be born into the state of butterflies upon
the moor, then
perchance we may be happy together!]
Nadeshiko ni
Chocho shiroshi --
Tare no kon? [11]
[On the pink-flower there is a white
butterfly: whose spirit, I wonder?]
Ichi-nichi no
Tsuma to miekeri --
Cho futatsu.
[The one-day wife has at last appeared -- a pair of butterflies!]
Kite wa mau,
Futari shidzuka no
Kocho kana!
[Approaching they dance; but when the two meet at last they are very
quiet, the butterflies!]
Cho wo ou
Kokoro-mochitashi
Itsumademo!
[Would that I might always have the heart (desire) of chasing butterflies![12]]
* * *
Besides these specimens of
poetry about butterflies, I have one queer
example to offer of Japanese prose
literature on the same topic. The
original, of which I have attempted only a free
translation, can be found
in the curious old book Mushi-Isame ("Insect-Admonitions"); and it assumes
the form of a
discourse to a
butterfly. But it is really a didactic
allegory,-- suggesting the moral
significance of a social rise and fall:--
"Now, under the sun of spring, the winds are gentle, and flowers pinkly
bloom, and grasses are soft, and the hearts of people are glad. Butterflies
everywhere
flutterjoyously: so many persons now
compose Chinese verses and
Japanese verses about butterflies.
"And this season, O Butterfly, is indeed the season of your bright
prosperity: so
comely you now are that in the whole world there is nothing
more
comely. For that reason all other insects admire and envy you;-- there
is not among them even one that does not envy you. Nor do insects alone
regard you with envy: men also both envy and admire you. Soshu of China, in
a dream, assumed your shape;-- Sakoku of Japan, after dying, took your
form, and
therein made
ghostlyapparition. Nor is the envy that you inspire
shared only by insects and mankind: even things without soul change their
form into yours;--
witness the barley-grass, which turns into a
butterfly.
[13]
"And
therefore you are lifted up with pride, and think to yourself: 'In all
this world there is nothing superior to me!' Ah! I can very well guess what
is in your heart: you are too much satisfied with your own person. That is
why you let yourself be blown thus
lightly about by every wind;-- that is
why you never remain still,-- always, always thinking, 'In the whole world
there is no one so
fortunate as I.'
"But now try to think a little about your own personal history. It is
worth recalling; for there is a
vulgar side to it. How a
vulgar side? Well,
for a
considerable time after you were born, you had no such reason for
rejoicing in your form. You were then a mere cabbage-insect, a hairy worm;
and you were so poor that you could not afford even one robe to cover your
nakedness; and your appearance was
altogether disgusting. Everybody in
those days hated the sight of you. Indeed you had good reason to be
ashamedof yourself; and so
ashamed you were that you collected old twigs and
rubbish to hide in, and you made a hiding-nest, and hung it to a branch,--
and then everybody cried out to you, 'Raincoat Insect!' (Mino-mushi.) [14]
And during that period of your life, your sins were
grievous. Among the
tender green leaves of beautiful cherry-trees you and your fellows
assembled, and there made ugliness
extraordinary; and the
expectant eyes of
the people, who came from far away to admire the beauty of those
cherry-trees, were hurt by the sight of you. And of things even more
hateful than this you were
guilty. You knew that poor, poor men and women
had been cultivating daikon (2) in their fields,-- toiling under the hot
sun till their hearts were filled with
bitterness by reason of having to
care for that daikon; and you persuaded your companions to go with you, and
to gather upon the leaves of that daikon, and on the leaves of other
vegetables planted by those poor people. Out of your greediness you ravaged
those leaves, and gnawed them into all shapes of ugliness,-- caring nothing
for the trouble of those poor folk... Yes, such a creature you were, and
such were your doings.
"And now that you have a
comely form, you
despise your old comrades, the
insects; and,
whenever you happen to meet any of them, you
pretend not to
know them [literally, 'You make an I-don't-know face']. Now you want to
have none but
wealthy and exalted people for friends... Ah! You have
forgotten the old times, have you?
"It is true that many people have forgotten your past, and are charmed by
the sight of your present
graceful shape and white wings, and write Chinese
verses and Japanese verses about you. The high-born
damsel, who could not
bear even to look at you in your former shape, now gazes at you with
delight, and wants you to perch upon her hairpin, and holds out her dainty
fan in the hope that you will light upon it. But this reminds me that there
is an ancient Chinese story about you, which is not pretty.
"In the time of the Emperor Genso, the Imperial Palace contained hundreds
and thousands of beautiful ladies,-- so many, indeed, that it would have
been difficult for any man to decide which among them was the loveliest.
So all of those beautiful persons were assembled together in one place; and
you were set free to fly among them; and it was decreed that the
damselupon whose hairpin you perched should be augustly summoned to the Imperial
Chamber. In that time there could not be more than one Empress -- which was
a good law; but, because of you, the Emperor Genso did great
mischief in
the land. For your mind is light and
frivolous; and although among so many
beautiful women there must have been some persons of pure heart, you would
look for nothing but beauty, and so betook yourself to the person most
beautiful in
outward appearance. Therefore many of the
female attendants
ceased
altogether to think about the right way of women, and began to study
how to make themselves appear splendid in the eyes of men. And the end of
it was that the Emperor Genso died a
pitiful and
painful death -- all
because of your light and
trifling mind. Indeed, your real
character can
easily be seen from your conduct in other matters. There are trees, for