A leading Chinese securities firm and a French bank with a brokerage in Hong Kong are teaming up to conduct an interesting experiment in the testing ground of China's capital markets.
Credit Agricole SA and China's Citic Securities Co. have reached a
preliminary deal to
explore combining some of their
equity businesses, according to people familiar with the situation. The tie-up, which still needs regulatory
approval in Beijing, would see a foreign
player for the first time join forces with a top-tier Chinese securities firm to underwrite and trade shares in China's
domestic market. It would also help the listed brokerage arm of state-owned Citic Group
strengthen its position in Hong Kong and
expand into China's Asian backyard.
A key
player in the deal is CLSA Asia-Pacific Markets, a Hong Kong-based brokerage 65%-owned by Credit Agricole.
Under the deal being envisioned, Citic Securities would become
partners in a joint
venture with CLSA to
operate in China's
domestic securities market after
taking over the stake of CLSA's current joint-
venturepartner, Hunan-based Fortune Securities Co Ltd., for an undisclosed sum. Citic Securities would own two-thirds of the
venture, with CLSA
holding the rest. Citic Securities would then
inject into the
venture all of its institutional broking business, including
research, underwriting and corporate finance.
Foreign banks have been eager to gain
access to China's fast-growing securities business. China's tight restrictions require them to hook up with local
partners and limit their stakes in any joint
ventures to 33%.
The most
prominent foreign joint
ventures are each
laboratory trials unto themselves, with very different structures. Goldman Sachs Group Inc. tied up with a deal maker, Fang Fenglei, and Legend Holdings Ltd., the parent company of Chinese
computer maker Lenovo Group Ltd., financing the
creation of a new business and then
partnering with it. UBS AG generally elicits the most envy from its peers for having a China operation with wide range of securities licenses, and over which it has de facto
management control
despite having only a 20% stake. But no one else has been allowed to copy its model.
UBS's China business ranked No. 7 in underwriting of
domestic Class A shares last year, according to Dealogic, ahead of any other Sino-foreign
ventures. By hitching its wagon to Citic Securities, the No. 2 A-share underwriter, CLSA would suddenly leap ahead in the
league tables. But
unlike UBS, it is almost certainly not going to have
management control over its
venture-- that would be a bit like
trying to tell the Los Angeles Lakers how to play basketball. No matter: any
arrangement would be an
improvement over CLSA's current China
venture, a minor
player in the industry.
Outside of China, however, Citic Securities needs help, and that is where CLSA comes in handy. CLSA isn't known as a major underwriter, but its
research is well-respected and it has a
substantial brokerage business in Hong Kong and other big Asian markets, where it would make sense for Citic Securities to look first in
expanding outside its home base. Citic Securities has been building up its business in H shares, or Hong Kong-listed
mainland Chinese companies, to complement its strength in A shares but could use CLSA's
distributionnetwork to raise its game.
Citic Securities already has some bankers,
researchers and traders in Hong Kong; much of that offshore business would fold into CLSA's operations as part of the new
alliance. Citic Securities will also purchase a
minority stake in CLSA from Credit Agricole, though how much and for what price hasn't been determined, people familiar with the talks say. Citic Securities would have
access to Credit Agricole's institutional broking
platform in Europe and the U.S. as well.
If the deal goes through, the risks of
partnering-- a tricky business under any circumstances, but especially so in China-- could yet be its
downfall. Morgan Stanley fell
victim to a sour
partnership. As a co-founder of China International Capital Corp. in the 1990s, it was a
pioneerinvestor" target="_blank" title="n.投资者">
investor in China's securities industry. But disagreements with the firm's
management led to a rift that
ultimately sidelined Morgan Stanley from having any say in how the
venture was run.
Morgan Stanley is finally close to getting out of that deal so it can try entering a new one where it might exercise more influence. Recently, CICC Chairman Li Jiange said Morgan Stanley has found buyers for a 34.3% stake in the Chinese
investment" target="_blank" title="n.投资;(时间等)投入">
investment bank. The buyers include private-
equity firms Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. and TPG Capital, and the stake should fetch more than $1
billion for Morgan Stanley, people familiar with the situation have said. It appears the deal is still awaiting final regulatory
approval.
Citic Securities knows the risk of bad
partnering too. In October 2007, the firm reached a deal with Bear Stearns for each to
invest $1
billion in the other. Luckily for Citic Securities, China's regulators took their time reviewing the plan, which meant that Bear Stearns collapsed before it was ever implemented.
Executives at Credit Agricole and Citic Securities no doubt hope their effort to
expand the boundaries of Chinese and foreign
cooperation in the securities business will prove more successful.