《War And Peace》　Book13 　CHAPTER X
　　　　by Leo Tolstoy

BUT, strange to say, all these arrangements, these efforts and plans, which
were no whit inferior to those that had been made on similar occasions before,
never touched the root of the matter; like the hands on the face of a clock,
when detached from the mechanism, they turned aimlessly and arbitrarily, without
catching the wheels.

The plan of campaign, that work of genius, of which Thiers says, that his
genius never imagined anything more profound, more skilful, and more admirable,
and entering into a polemical discussion with M. Fenn, proves that the
composition of this work of genius is to be referred, not to the 4th, but to the
15th of October-that plan never was and never could be put into execution,
because it had nothing in common with the actual facts of the position. The
fortification of the Kremlin, for which it was necessary to pull down la Mosquée
(as Napoleon called the church of Vassily the Blessed) turned out to be
perfectly useless. The mining of the Kremlin was only of use for carrying out
the desire the Emperor expressed on leaving Moscow, to blow up the Kremlin, like
a child that beats the floor against which it has hurt itself. The pursuit of
the Russian army, on which Napoleon laid so much stress, led to an unheard-of
result. The French generals lost sight of the sixty thousand men of the Russian
army, and it was only, in the words of Thiers, thanks to the skill, and
apparently also the genius, of Murat that they succeeded at last in finding,
like a lost pin, this army of sixty thousand men.

On the diplomatic side, all Napoleon's expositions of his magnanimity and
justice, both to Tutolmin and to Yakovlev (the latter was principally interested
in finding himself a great-coat and a conveyance for travelling) turned out to
be fruitless. Alexander would not receive these envoys, and made no reply to the
message they brought.

On the side of law, of order, after the execution of the supposed
incendiaries, the other half of Moscow was burnt down.

The establishment of a municipal council did not check pillage, and was no
benefit to any one but the few persons, who were members of it, and were able on
the pretext of preserving order to plunder Moscow on their own account, or to
save their own property from being plundered.

On the religious side, the difficulty had so easily been settled by
Napoleon's visit to a mosque in Egypt, but here similar measures led to no
results whatever. Two or three priests, picked up in Moscow, did attempt to
carry out Napoleon's desire; but one of them was slapped in the face by a French
soldier during the service, and in regard to the other, the following report was
made by a French official: "The priest, whom I had discovered and invited to
resume saying the Mass, cleaned and closed the church. In the night they came
again to break in the doors, break the padlocks, tear the books, and commit
other disorders."

As for the encouragement of commerce, the proclamation to "industrious
artisans and peasants," met with no response at all. Industrious artisans there
were none in Moscow, and the peasants set upon the messengers who ventured too
far from the town with this proclamation and killed them.

The attempts to entertain the people and the troops with theatres were
equally unsuccessful. The theatres set up in the Kremlin and Poznyakov's house
were closed again immediately, because the actors and actresses were stripped of
their belongings by the soldiers.

Even philanthropy did not bring the desired results. Moscow was full of paper
money, genuine and counterfeit, and the notes had no value. The French,
accumulating booty, cared for nothing but gold. The counterfeit notes, which
Napoleon so generously bestowed on the unfortunate, were of no value, and even
silver fell below its standard value in relation to gold.

But the most striking example of the ineffectiveness of all efforts made by
the authorities was Napoleon's vain endeavour to check plunder, and to maintain
discipline.

Here are reports sent in by the military authorities:

"Pillage continues in the city, in spite of the orders to stop it. Order is
not yet restored, and there is not a single merchant carrying on trade in a
lawful fashion. But the canteen-keepers permit themselves to sell the fruits of
pillage.

"Part of my district continues to be a prey to the pillaging of the soldiers
of the 3rd corps who, not satisfied with tearing from the poor wretches, who
have taken refuge in the underground cellars, the little they have left, have
even the ferocity to wound them with sword-cuts, as I have seen in several
instances.

"Nothing new, but that the soldiers give themselves up to robbery and
plunder. October 9th.

"Robbery and pillage continue. There is a band of robbers in our district,
which would need strong guards to arrest it. October 11th.

"The Emperor is exceedingly displeased that, in spite of the strict orders to
stop pillage, bands of marauders from the guards are continually returning to
the Kremlin. In the Old Guards, the disorder and pillaging have been more
violent than ever last night and to-day. The Emperor sees, with regret, that the
picked soldiers, appointed to guard his person, who should set an example to the
rest, are losing discipline to such a degree as to break into the cellars and
stores prepared for the army. Others are so degraded that they refuse to obey
sentinels and officers on guard, abuse them, and strike them.

"The chief marshal of the palace complains bitterly that, in spite of
repeated prohibitions, the soldiers continue to commit nuisances in all the
courtyards, and even before the Emperor's own windows."

The army, like a herd of cattle run wild, and trampling underfoot the fodder
that might have saved them from starvation, was falling to pieces, and getting
nearer to its ruin with every day it remained in Moscow.

But it did not move.

It only started running when it was seized by panic fear at the capture of a
transport on the Smolensk road and the battle of Tarutino. The news of the
battle of Tarutino reached Napoleon unexpectedly in the middle of a review, and
aroused in him-so Thiers tells us-a desire to punish the Russians, and he gave
the order for departure that all the army was clamouring for.

In their flight from Moscow, the soldiers carried with them all the plunder
they had collected. Napoleon, too, carried off his own private trésor.
Seeing the great train of waggons, loaded with the booty of the army, Napoleon
was alarmed (as Thiers tells us). But with his military experience, he did not
order all unnecessary waggons of goods to be burnt, as he had done with a
marshal's baggage on the way to Moscow. He gazed at those carts and carriages,
filled with soldiers, and said that it was very well, that those conveyances
would come in useful for provisions, the sick, and the wounded.

The plight of the army was like the plight of a wounded beast, that feels its
death at hand, and knows not what it is doing. Studying the intricate manœuvres
and schemes of Napoleon and his army from the time of entering Moscow up to the
time of the destruction of that army is much like watching the death struggles
and convulsions of a beast mortally wounded. Very often the wounded creature,
hearing a stir, rushes to meet the hunter's shot, runs forward and back again,
and itself hastens its end. Napoleon under the pressure of his army did
likewise. Panic-stricken at the rumour of the battle of Tarutino, like a wild
beast, the army made a rush towards the shot, reached the hunter, and ran back
again; and at last, like every wild creature took the old familiar track, that
was the worst and most disastrous way for it.

Napoleon is represented to us as the leader in all this movement, just as the
figurehead in the prow of a ship to the savage seems the force that guides the
ship on its course. Napoleon in his activity all this time was like a child,
sitting in a carriage, pulling the straps within it, and fancying he is moving
it along.