young man could hardly
restrain a strong desire to strike the critic.
"Ah! that is the question," said the little old man. "You are floating
between two systems,--between
drawing and color, between the patient
phlegm and honest stiffness of the old Dutch masters and the dazzling
warmth and abounding joy of the Italians. You have tried to follow, at
one and the same time, Hans Holbein and Titian; Albrecht Durier and
Paul Veronese. Well, well! it was a
gloriousambition, but what is the
result? You have neither the stern
attraction of
severity nor the
deceptive magic of the chiaroscuro. See! at this place the rich, clear
color of Titian has forced out the
skeletonoutline of Albrecht
Durier, as
moltenbronze might burst and
overflow a
slender mould.
Here and there the
outline has resisted the flood, and holds back the
magnificent
torrent of Venetian color. Your figure is neither
perfectly well painted nor
perfectly well drawn; it bears throughout
the signs of this
unfortunate indecision. If you did not feel that the
fire of your
genius was hot enough to weld into one the rival methods,
you ought to have chosen
honestly the one or the other, and thus
attained the unity which conveys one
aspect, at least, of life. As it
is, you are true only on your middle plane. Your
outlines are false;
they do not round upon themselves; they suggest nothing behind them.
There is truth here," said the old man, pointing to the bosom of the
saint; "and here," showing the spot where the shoulder ended against
the
background; "but there," he added, returning to the
throat, "it is
all false. Do not inquire into the why and
wherefore. I should fill
you with despair."
The old man sat down on a stool and held his head in his hands for
some minutes in silence.
"Master," said Porbus at length, "I
studied that
throat from the nude;
but, to our sorrow, there are effects in nature which become false or
impossible when placed on
canvas."
"The
mission of art is not to copy nature, but to represent it. You
are not an
abject copyist, but a poet," cried the old man, hastily
interrupting Porbus with a despotic
gesture. "If it were not so, a
sculptor could reach the
height of his art by merely
moulding a woman.
Try to mould the hand of your
mistress, and see what you will get,--
ghastly articulations, without the slightest re
semblance to her living
hand; you must have
recourse to the
chisel of a man who, without
servilely copying that hand, can give it
movement and life. It is our
mission to seize the mind, soul,
countenance of things and beings.
Effects! effects! what are they? the mere accidents of the life, and
not the life itself. A hand,--since I have taken that as an example,--
a hand is not merely a part of the body, it is far more; it expresses
and carries on a thought which we must seize and render. Neither the
painter nor the poet nor the
sculptor should separate the effect from
the cause, for they are indissolubly one. The true struggle of art
lies there. Many a
painter has triumphed through
instinct without
knowing this theory of art as a theory.
"Yes," continued the old man vehemently, "you draw a woman, but you do
not SEE her. That is not the way to force an entrance into the arcana
of Nature. Your hand reproduces, without an action of your mind, the
model you copied under a master. You do not search out the secrets of
form, nor follow its windings and evolutions with enough love and
perseverance. Beauty is
solemn and
severe, and cannot be attained in
that way; we must wait and watch its times and seasons, and clasp it
firmly ere it yields to us. Form is a Proteus less easily captured,