well. Michel Tatu, a prominent French Kremlinologist and author
of a
forthcomingbiography of Gorbachev, is convinced that he
joined in the
vicious anti-Semitic
rhetoric of Stalin's last
purge, launched just before the dictator's death in early 1953.
Mlynar does not deny that, but he insists that Gorbachev
steered clear of any individual persecutions.
By 1955, the year of Gorbachev's
graduation, the Stalinist ice
had broken in the Soviet Union, Nikita Khrushchev had taken over
and was winding down the terror. Ghostly figures began drifting
back into Moscow from the labor camps. But at the start of this
period of
ferment and change, Gorbachev removed himself and
Raisa from the relative sophistication of Moscow and returned
to the Stavropol area, where he was to stay for the next 23
years. According to Neznansky, the young graduate tried for a
position with the Moscow Komsomol
apparatus but lost out to a
classmate and had little choice but to return to the provinces
if he wanted to continue a career in party politics. It may be
too that Gorbachev felt an obligation to the Stavropol Krai
(territory) authorities, who had
apparently paid part of his
university expenses, or that he was simply homesick.
In any event, the Stavropol period remains the most obscure of
Gorbachev's life. It is known that he rose fast, from a minor
job in the local Komsomol to its first secretary after less than
a year, then through a variety of Komsomol and, later, party
jobs. By 1962, when he was only 31, he was choosing party
members for
promotion throughout Stavropol Krai. Finally in
1970, at the age of 39, he became first secretary of the
territory, a job
equivalent to governor of an area
roughly the
size of South Carolina, with about 2.4 million people. Along
the way, he became a
specialist in farming, the main activity
of the area. He took
correspondence courses from Stavropol
Agricultural Institute, and in 1967 added a degree in
agriculture to his Moscow law degree. Soviet emigres and
Stavropol residents provide some intriguing glimpses of
Gorbachev on his way up the party apparat.
Gorbachev showed an avid interest in the press. Vladimir
Maximov, a writer now living in Paris who worked for a Stavropol
Komsomol newspaper in the 1950s, recalls that the young official
often visited the paper's offices for a chat. "He would sit
down with us in a
casual manner," says Maximov. "We would
uncork a bottle of wine [for all his antialcoholism
campaigning,
Gorbachev still enjoys an occasional drink] and usually talk
politics. Khrushchev's report on the crimes of the Stalinist
era had recently appeared. The entire country was still reeling
from shock." Maximov and others of Gorbachev's generation,
however, remember the late 1950s as an exciting time.
Khrushchev's secret speech denouncing Stalin at the 20th
Communist Party Congress in 1956 briefly opened the way to a
much freer atmosphere. It was false dawn. Repression resumed
a few years later. To this day, however, educated SOviets of
Gorbachev's generation, whose political attitudes were formed
then and who are now moving into positions of power, sometimes
refer to themselves as "children of the 20th Congress."
Gorbachev's interest in the press continued throughout the
Stavropol period. As party boss of the area, he often met with
regional journalists for talks similar to those he now holds in
Moscow with the national press. Unlike other party officials,
he would stress that it was not enough for the journalists to
write articles that were ideologically correct; they also had
to be interesting. "Is anyone reading what you write?" he would
ask.
Gorbachev remained open and
accessible to his constituents. He
usually set out on foot for his job each morning.
Stavropolitans quickly
learned that they could avoid having to
make a formal appointment at Gorbachev's office on Lenin Square
by buttonholing him on his walk up Dzerzhinsky Street and
discussing their problems then. He also began in Stavropol Krai
the walkabouts that were later to cause a national sensation
when he continued the practice as General Secretary. On a visit
to a village in the Izobilnynsky district, he heard from an
indignant mother of six children how the manager of a state
store had treated her
rudely. The storekeeper was fired.
Gorbachev showed some independence from Moscow when he was
Stavropol party boss. Turned down for state financing of a
permanent
circus building, he solicited funds from local
organizations and institutions and got the building put up
anyway.
The Gorbachevs relieved the
monotony of
provincial life with
several trips to Western Europe, Mikhail traveling as a member
of party
delegations visiting foreign Communists and Raisa once
or twice accompanying him. On the first trip, in 1966,
Gorbachev later recalled, the couple rented a Renault and spent
several weeks driving 3,400 miles through the length and breadth
of France, with a side trip to Italy.
Was Gorbachev getting restless with
provincial posts? Perhaps.
Mlynar, who was rising toward the top level of the Czech
Communist Party, visited his old classmate in 1967 and recalls
that Gorbachev complained about
excessiveinterference by Moscow
in local affairs. Mlynar described the
sweeping reforms that
Alexander Dubcek was then beginning in Czechoslovakia. He
remembers Gorbachev
saying, with a sign, "Perhaps there are
possibilities in Czechoslovakia because conditions are
different." The Czech reforms, however, were crushed by Soviet
tanks the following year, and Mlynar went into exile; he now
lives in Austria. The two old friends talked and drank through
that afternoon and deep into the night. When they finally
returned to Gorbachev's apartment, much the worse for wear,
Raisa was furious.
Just how Gorbachev rose out of
provincialobscurity is still
somewhat mysterious. As late as 1978, few outside Stavropol
Krai had ever heard of him. The best answer seems to be that
he attracted a number of powerful patrons. The first was Fyodor
Kulakov, who as party boss in Stavropol first spotted Gorbachev
as having great promise. After Kulakov became Agriculture
Secretary for the entire Soviet Union, Gorbachev
eventuallysucceeded him in Stavropol--and Kulakov
apparently made sure his
protege became known in Moscow. In 1977 the "Ipatovsky method,"
a new
technique of harvesting grain quickly by using flying
squads of combines, was judged a smashing success. The idea was
probably Kulakov's, but it was first tried in the district of
Ipatovsky, in Stavropol Krai, under Gorbachev's supervision.
The young regional politician was accorded the honor of an
interview on the front page of Pravda, his first taste of
national publicity.
Geography gave Gorbachev a
mighty assist too. Christian
Schmidt- Hauer, a West German journalist and biographer,
observes that if Gorbachev had been party chief in, say,
Murmansk in the far north, he would never have become General
Secretary. But in Stavropol Krai, he was on hand to welcome top
Moscow officials who came to the local spas at Mineralnye Vody
and Kislovodsk for vacations and medical treatment. They found
their host unusual in several respects. Says Soviet Historian
Roy Medvedev: "A regional party first secretary who was
intelligent and
congenial would have been considered un
typical.
If Gorbachev had yelled, sworn, been a heavy drinker or a high
liver with a rest house outside of town where officials could
be entertained by pretty waitresses, that would have been
considered normal behavior."
Gorbachev was not like that at all. He was a quiet and pleasant
host with a
reputation throughout the district for
incorruptibility. Writer Maximov relates a story about a mutual
friend, a poet, who asked Gorbachev as a young Komsomol official
to help him buy a Volga sedan. Gorbachev obligingly used his
influence to speed
delivery. The poet promptly sold the car on
the black market and returned to ask Gorbachev for help in
buying another. Says Maximov: "Gorbachev did not usually lose
his temper, but on that occasion he started shouting and threw
the poet out of his office, ordering him never to show his face
there again."
The young party chief's
reputation pleased two important spa
guests: Mikhail Suslov, then the chief Soviet ideologist, and
KGB Chief Yuri Andropov, both
austere figures disgusted by the
corruption of the Brezhnev era. When Kulakov died in 1978, he
left vacant the position of Communist Party Central Committee
Secretary in charge of agriculture. To fill it, General
Secretary Leonid Brezhnev,
presumably acting on the advice of
Suslov and Andropov, chose a man he had evidently met only
recently: Gorbachev. That meeting occurred on Sept. 19, 1978,
at the tiny railroad station in Mineralnye Vody, where
Brezhnev's train stopped for a brief time. In one of the more
remarkable moments in Soviet history, four men who were all to
serve as General Secretary found themselves on the same narrow
station platform: Brezhnev; Andropov, who had come over from
the nearby spa and in 1982 would succeed Brezhnev; Konstantin
Chernenko, then Brezhnev's chief aide and in 1984 Andropov's
successor; and Gorbachev, who would take over from Chernenko as
General Secretary the following year. Less than a month after
that
gathering, Gorbachev was plucked out of Stavropol to
become, at 47, a member of the national hierarchy, ranking 20th
among all Soviet leaders.
How he leaped from there to No. 1 in only seven more years is
another question still not fully answered. Certainly his rise
was not attributable to any glittering success in agriculture.
Quite the opposite: the grain harvest fell from a record 230
million tons in 1978, when Gorbachev was
taking over the
agriculture portfolio, to a calamitous total of perhaps only 155
million tons in 1981. Bad weather played a role. So did
Brezhnev, who announced a grandiose
reorganization of
agriculture that seemed to create more problems than it solved.
Still, it is remarkable that Gorbachev managed not only to
escape blame but to advance his career amid the farming fiasco.
Only a year after returning to Moscow, he became a candidate
member of the Politburo. The following year, at 49, he was made
a full member. Gorbachev was eight years younger than the next
youngest Politburo member and 21 years younger than the average
age of his colleagues.
One reason Gorbachev's agriculture record was not held against
him was imply that the Kremlin
leadership found itself in
desperate need of new blood. Brezhnev's health was faltering,
and his 18-year
regime was sinking into a twilight of stagnation
and
corruption. When Brezhnev died in 1982 and Andropov came
into office with plans for reform, he immediately began grooming
Gorbachev to become a key lieutenant in his clean-up
campaign.
Gorbachev was already preparing himself for national
leadership. While still in charge of farming, he gathered Soviet
academic experts for a series f seminars held sometimes in the
Central Committee offices, sometimes in a dacha outside Moscow.
The
sessions started with problems of agriculture but quickly
developed into freewheeling discussions of what was wrong with
the economy in general and how it might be fixed. Among the
participants were Economists Abel Aganbegyan, who had been
urging decentralization and a wider role for market
incentives
since the mid-1960s, and Tatyana Zaslavskaya, a leading
sociologist. Zaslavskaya recalls one encounter with Gorbachev:
"I sat next to him. It is
incredible what power and drive
emanate from him. One feels as if it were a strong field of
energy. His
vitality is extraordinary, and yet, although you
feel this
tension, he is a good
listener and waits for you to
finish."
The rising Kremlin star got a firsthand look at how far the
Soviet economy had fallen behind the West's. When Gorbachev
joined the national hierarchy, he was already well
traveled by
comparison with such other Soviet leaders at Andropov. who never
set foot outside the Communist world, and Suslov, who reportedly
once told a visa
applicant that he saw no reason why anyone
would want to journey beyond he U.S.S.R.
As a Politburo member Gorbachev in 1983 headed a Soviet
agricultural
delegation on a visit to Canada and spent ten days
poking around farms, processing plants and supermarkets. At one
cattle ranch, he asked to see "some of the workers." The
rancher replied that there were none; he ran the spread of
several hundred acres with only his family and
handful of day
laborers. A Canadian host who speaks Russian heard Gorbachev
mutter under his breath, "We are not going to see this [in the
Soviet Union] for another 50 years." Eugene Whelan, then
Minister of Agriculture and Gorbachev's official host, was
surprised on another occasion to hear the Soviet leader comment
about the
invasion of Afghanistan: "It was a mistake." (He was
later to call Afghanistan a "bleeding wound," but in public he
still justifies the
invasion.) In the same year, however,
Gorbachev served on a Politburo crisis-management subgroup that
sought to justify the Soviet downing of a Korean Air Lines
passenger jet by asserting that the plane had been on a spying
mission for the U.S.
By the time a fatal
kidneyailment cut short Andropov's tenure
in early 1984, Gorbachev was already a candidate to succeed his
former mentor. At Andropov's funeral, Gorbachev made a telling
gesture of his closeness to the late General Secretary: he was
the only Politburo member
publicly to
console Andropov's
bereaved widow Tatyana. But the Old Guard made a final stand,
choosing Chernenko instead. Gorbachev went along, and even
agreed to make the nominating speech. He probably knew his turn
would come soon enough. Ailing and 72, Chernenko was not going
to last long. In fact, through much of his year in power
Chernenko was so ill that Gorbachev, his principal
deputy, in
effect ran the country.
Even so, he had opposition. Grigori Romanov, the hard-line
former Leningrad party boss who was once thought be Gorbachev's
chief rival, had
apparently given up on
winning the top job for
himself. But at the Politburo
session called immediately after
Chernenko's death, Romanov reportedly tried a stop-Gorbachev
maneuver, nominating Moscow Party Boss Viktor Grishin for
General Secretary. By some accounts, however, KGB Chief Viktor
Chebrikov hinted that his agency had compiled dossiers on the
corruption in the moscow party
apparatus that could be highly
embarrassing to Grishin. (Chebrikov was then a candidate member
of the Politburo; he has since moved up to full membership.)
Andrei Gromyko, then Foreign Minister, carried the day with a
nominating speech for Gorbachev during which he coined the now
celebrated remark, "This man has a nice smile, but he has iron
teeth." Gromyko's speech was surprising in two respects: it
appears to have been improvised, and it contained none of the
lengthy recitation of the hero's accomplishments
traditional on
such occasions. Gromyko appeared to be
saying: this man has
not really done all that much yet, but he is still the best we
have.
Gorbachev had been in power only a month when he roamed around
the industrial Proletarsky district of Moscow, visiting
supermarkets, chatting with workers at the Likhachyov truck
factory, discussing computer training with teachers at School
No. 514 and nurses' pay with the staff of City Hospital No. 53.
He even dropped into a young couple's apartment for tea. That
was the first of the walkabouts that have taken him, sometimes
accompanied by Raisa, from Murmansk in the north to Kamchatka